Your field guide to gay men's health. The blog is no longer active, but is still available to use as an information resource.
Tuesday, November 6, 2007
How risky is...?
So this little chart, from a presentation on sero-adaptation you can find here, shows the relative risks of various unprotected sexual acts. I am including a version, below, done by the wonderful Trevor Hoppe who added translations in "gay speak."
What does this chart mean? Well, giving or receiving head is rather low risk, and getting fucked without a condom? Rather high risk. Topping someone without a condom? Significantly lower risk than not using a condom while bottoming. This puts it all together so you can look at relative risk comparing various activities.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
select key words
2007 National HIV Prevention Conference
2009 National LGBTI Health Summit
2011 LGBTI Health Summit
2012 Gay Men's Health Summit
2012 International AIDS Conference
abstinence only
ACT Up
activism
advocacy
Africa
african-american
aging issues
AIDS
AIDS Foundation of Chicago
anal cancer
anal carcinoma
anal health
anal sex
andrew's anus
athlete
ball scene
bareback porn
barebacking
bathhouses
bears
big bold and beautiful
Bisexual
Bisexual Health Summit
bisexuality
black gay men
black msm
blood ban
blood donor
body image
bottom
Brian Mustanski
BUTT
Center on Halsted
Charles Stephens
Chicago
Chicago Black Gay Men's Caucus
Chicago Task Force on LGBT Substance Use and Abuse
Chris Bartlett
chubby chaser
circumcision
civil rights
civil union
Coaching with Jake
communication
community organizing
condoms
Congress
crystal meth
dating
dating and mating with alan irgang
David Halperin
David Munar
depression
disclosure
discrimination
domestic violence
don't ask don't tell
douche
downlow
Dr. James Holsinger
Dr. Jesus Ramirez-Valles
Dr. Rafael Diaz
Dr. Ron Stall
drag queen
Ed Negron
emotional health
ENDA
Eric Rofes
exercise
Feast of Fun
Feel the love...
female condom
fitness
Friday is for Faeries
FTM
gay culture
gay identity
gay latino
gay male sex
gay marriage
gay men
gay men of color
gay men's health
Gay Men's Health Summit 2010
gay pride
gay rights
gay rugby
gay sex
gay youth
gender
harm reduction
hate crime
HCV
health care
health care reform
health insurance
hepatitis C
HIV
HIV care
HIV drugs
HIV negative
HIV positive
HIV prevention
HIV stigma
HIV strategic plan
HIV testing
hiv vaccine
HIV/AIDS
homophobia
homosexuality
hottie
hotties
how are you healthy?
Howard Brown Health Center
HPV
human rights
humor
hunk
Illinois
IML
immigration
International AIDS Conference
international mr. leather
internet
intimacy
IRMA
Jim Pickett
leather community
leathersex
Leon Liberman
LGBT
LGBT adoption
LGBT culture
LGBT health
LGBT rights
LGBT seniors
LGBT youth
LGBTI community
LGBTI culture
LGBTI health
LGBTI rights
LGBTI spirituality
LGV
LifeLube
LifeLube forum
LifeLube poll
LifeLube subscription
lifelube survey
Lorenzo Herrera y Lozano
love
lube
lubricant
Lymphogranuloma Venereum
masturbation
mental health
microbicides
middle
Monday Morning Perk-Up
MRSA
MSM
music
National AIDS Strategy
National Gay Men's Health Summit
negotiated safety
nutrition
One Fey's Tale
oral sex
Peter Pointers
physical health
Pistol Pete
pleasure
PnP
podcast
policy
politics
poppers
porn
post-exposure prophylaxis
PrEP
President Barack Obama
Presidential Campaign
prevention
Project CRYSP
prostate
prostate cancer
public health
public sex venues
queer identity
racism
Radical Faerie
recovery
rectal microbicides
relationships
religion
research
safe sex
semen
Senator Barack Obama
sero-adaptation
sero-sorting
seroguessing
sex
sexual abuse
sexual addiction
sexual health
sexual orientation
Sister Glo
Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence
smoking
social marketing
spirituality
STD
stigma
stonewall riots
substance abuse treatment
substance use
suicide
super-bug
superinfection
Susan Kingston
Swiss declaration
syphilis
Ted Kerr
Test Positive Aware Network
testicle self-examination
testicular cancer
testing
The "Work-In"
The 2009 Gay Men's Health Agenda
Tony Valenzuela
top
Trans and Intersex Association
trans group blog
Trans Gynecology Access Program
transgender
transgender day of remembrance
transgendered
transmen
transphobia
transsexual
Trevor Hoppe
universal health care
unsafe sex
vaccines
video
violence
viral load
Who's That Queer
Woof Wednesday
writers
yoga
You Tube
youtube
Ranking risk of one sexual practice is another harm reduction myth. We don't know before and during sex what might happen next in a moment when the heart is beating faster and the mind is numbed. Generally during sex people don't do one thing and stop. So risk assessment of one sexual practice can be deceptive especially selfdeceptive. The next moment after one sexual practice can be something different and unexpected. The unexpected, spontaneity is part of the nature of sexuality that isn't taken into account in ranking risk of one sexual practice.
ReplyDeleteI think the myth here is that men can't make rational decisions about sex and sexual behaviors - before or during sex. Many, many gay men since the beginning of the AIDS epidemic have chosen one activity over another, or chosen to avoid one altogether, as a means of harm reduction. The view you espouse likens adults to infants - and sorry, I don't buy it.
ReplyDeleteJim
You mean like life is rational?... I mean math and science are rational but they aren't a big part of the life of most people because it's hard to do math and science during sex.
ReplyDelete_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
> likens adults to infants
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Well, we can say two things about that. Well, generally, infants don't do math and science. While infants can be irrational, they generally don't do sex either. When we're talking about sexuality there's another train track of irrationality that runs parallel to it.
When you think about it during sex you're distracted from it. For most animals sex goes pretty fast unless you're a top predator. You have to think about these things in the long run of history. And sex today is probably safer than when you would be eaten after sex. Living things have to thrown into a state of irrationality where they ignore reality to have sex for the species to reproduce but it's also dangerous and you're presenting twice the target to another individual. Another animal going around looking for something to eat is going to have a real treat. If you look at it from the biological point of view sex is very dangerous because you're subject to being attacked.
I also would add into the conversation the fact that transmen have entered into gay men's communities and thus have changed our ability to distinguish between what the bodies of self-identified gay men look like - and what kind of sex (anal v. vaginal) gay men are having!
ReplyDeleteThanks for bringing this issue up, Chris!
xoxo
Trevor
I really appreciate all the dialogue around this. I agree --- with all the caveats, this chart is still an important tool we can use to talk about risk and what our levels of comfort are with various activities. It's about the discussion, really, more so than hard and fast numbers.
ReplyDeleteMWAH
Jim